I want a fake lash looking mascara?

I really want a mascara that gives a fake lash look, its waterproof and it doesn't flake, clump or smudge throughout the day, the problem i find with mascaras its not that i can't get the desired effect but after a couple of hours because i have combination skin I find black smudges just beneath my lower lashes (where dark circles could be). Also a key factor is the price I really don't want to spend anymore than �8. The last mascara I had was the maybelliene Great Lash, it gets them high and curly, but they look like spiders and smudges terribly! Even though I had heard such rave reviews. The mascara I have used to date with the most success is the Maybelliene define-a-lash, which was fab at lengthening but wasn't very good at thickening.